What is better? Eragon or Eldest?

i have always wondered which you guys like better, eragon or eldest. i like eldest better. well, mainly it's because it had a lot of arya in it, and i like arya. and more dragons, lots more dragons than before. see ya!

Arya08 you are brillant!!!! why didn't i think of that??? I am sooooo much smarter than you!! JK! i am hyper!!!! Cheers for Arya08!!!!

i couldn't decide, cuz eragon is a good start to the trilogy, but eldest was a bit longer i think, and i like long books, anyway, thanx for putting Bartimaeus in there for me, arya08.

yeah, eragon is a good starting book. i like how eragon and eldest are so descriptive and exciting. it really is hard to choose over them!

ya, i was really excited at the end of the 2nd book cuz MURTAGH WAS ALIVE i was very happy even if he was on the dark side... but i liked eragon 2 though the ending wasn't quite as exciting.

I liked Eldest better because of it's ending.

ARAY08 NEEDS TO DIE! i HATE ARAY! I DECLARE YOU MY MORTAL ENEMY! I'VE ONLY READ, LIKE 6 OF YOUR POSTS!

ya, the ending of the second is my favorite part of the whole trilogy, so far at least

I love Murtagh. he is so hott. I love Eldest because of him.

why do you spell aryas name wrong...do you really hate her that much that you cant even honor her name?!?!?! *cools down* eldest ending was tearjerking...i cried but iknew murtagh wasnt dead cause eragon caught a flick of movement when he scryed him

arya, aray, who cares? She still needs to die.

true.

Is Arya08 a due, girl,, or somthin else? Cuz who could honestly like arya?

leave her alone were all intitled to our own opionins..*coughs* hate arya

Sorry. but it was a real question, no offence

*smacks* *hugs*

*crys**runs away**runsback**squezedes till 1/2 dead*

*wheeze* *pushes away* i feel all fuzzy inside

me too, oh,wait, thats just my linner {lunch/dinner}

Why cant arya just go die and eragon join murtagh on the good-lookin evil side? And murtagh walk around with out a shirt on?